Leave a Comment:
9 comments
Well, in life, things mostly become obvious on hindsight. But that’s not to excuse GIC’s so-so performance. Having said that, GIC investments are held widely with alot of it believed to be US Govt bonds guarantee to give low returns.
Well, Tony Tan was in-charge of GIC for past many years. He is now running for elected President; and if you think he steered GIC poorly, then you got to think whether you want him to be your elected President?
ReplySender,
I always felt that the existence of two mega entities in the form of GIC and Temasek Holdings is unnecessary. I can understand having one but why do you need to have two when it adds another layer of costs?
ReplyMeasured against the stable value of gold, GIC results are much much worse.
Paraphrasing:
“If I had held GOLD at home in my biscuit tin can over the last twenty years, I would have been able to achieve a nice performance return if I choose to measure it in USD or SGD terms.”
Cheers ๐
ReplyNorman,
Probably the government would have done better by using investing all their reserves into gold. Don’t need for all the staff at GIC and Temasek.
ReplyIf GIC, (our govt’s investment arm, who hires the best financial brains) can muster only a “gross” annual retn of 7.0 (ave over 3 years, not taking into consideration inflation and foreign exchg gains) … Let those who has brains think. Humm…
ReplyThe next time when USD strengthen, just assume it would, then GIC performance will measure in Ringgit…..:-)
Forget it! We need to transparency and good governance of our people money and asset.
This bring up the issue of coming presidency election. Do we still want to elect another former member from the ruling party or we want a neutral candidates like Tan Kin Lian or Dr Tan Cheng Bock. Coincidentally, all candidates are from the TAN families.
Personally, would consider voting for either Mr Tan Kin Lian or Dr Tan Cheng Bock. Hope we would have a president like our most beloved former president, Mr Ong Teng Cheong, who dare to question and challenge the ruling party.
ReplyJason,
I think we have to see who even gets the COE to run in the first place.
ReplyOver last 10 yrs, USD depreciated against SGD by -3.9% p.a.
Over 5 yrs, it is -5.35% p.a.
So actual returns in SGD terms are roughly similar to wholelife and endowments. You can now tell people that your insurance company as good as GIC. Hiaks hiaks!
You can also see that pace of depreciation started in recent years, especially from 2008 with the “money printing”. MAS is also guilty of this, but to much lesser extent than US.
ReplyDear Nuts,
I think if you factor in inflation, the real return would be close to 0% or even negative. ๐
Reply